I grew up being taken to whoever was performing in Bournemouth. We saw Fille Mal Gardee the first time it travelled to the provinces and my Mother liked it so much we saw it twice. I was about 8 or 9 at the time but even then I could see there was a world of difference when we saw Doreen Wells and Christopher Gable take the lead roles.
Later on I lived in New York in the glory days of Baryshnikov, Makarova, Kirkland and Bujones mentioned by Meunier .....(did we ever meet I wonder?)With such dancers performing regularly, it was an absolute no-brainer to wait until the casting was published. At $9 a seat up in the Family Circle we could afford to go two or three times a week but we were still very picky as to who we saw dance! We were even known to go only to see Bujones dance the Corsaire pas de deux..at $1 a minute it was well worth it!
Now I live in Bristol and it is a slog to get to Covent Garden (or the Coliseum). It is nice to compare different dancers' interpretations, but this is somewhat of a luxury for us. Higher ticket prices and the knowledge we won't be home until 1.30 am have honed our choices down to the bone, even to the point of exchanging tickets should a our chosen dancer be injured. (We were at the Kobborg/ Cojacaru performance of Mayerling in June because I'd exchanged the tickets when Johan dropped out of their earlier performances, so that was a real bit of luck! )
If we don't know the company well I try to look up the dancers on You Tube to see what they are like. Didn't bother with the Stanislavsky having seen bits of their version of Coppelia posted there. Also Polunin never seemed to be bothered in most of the performances we saw at Covent Garden, so we decided to return the compliment!
I'm finding it very frustrating that ENB are so slow to release casting information. I have a feeling we will be seeing a lot more of them with both Tamara and Alina dancing. Do Friends get more information?
Obviously we have favourite ballets but we have discovered so many new and interesting things by booking to see a particular dancer (especially in New York......Push Comes to Shove, Great Galloping Gottschalk, La Sonambula etc. etc). So yes I pick by dancer every time. Osipova/Vailiev may just bankrupt me!