I saw this last night at High Wycombe and loved this production. It's so interesting seeing the variety of responses to different versions as well. Personally I really loved the framing story with the older Albrecht, and I found the ending very menacing with the advance of the Wilis on Albrecht to silence apart from the toll of the church bells. It also made good use of the loud closing music in the score- if my memory serves me correctly, I don't think the recent Bolshoi production used that but ended quietly and for some reason I really missed those final bars. We saw Mayu Tanigaito's Giselle, which radiated innocence. I liked the way the production felt more modern with the dress looking Victorian- it made Giselle seem like a symbol of an innocence associated with a past world that would disappear over the next few decades with the developments and the next century and the First World War. I also loved the flower symbolism and the tree and roots on the backcloth. Everything seemed made to work together and no moment was wasted. I liked Carlo Di Lanno's Albrecht which showed his bred nobility that he couldn't disguise, and Paul Mathews Hilarion made me really care about his character. Only bit I wasnt' sure I liked was the village idiot figure pulling the wedding cart. Loved the portrayal of the nobility- they seemed really nasty and abrupt, and the crooked dwellings of the peasants emphasised the class aspect. It was interesting that Abigail Boyle played both Bathilde and Myrtha-a bit of doubling that really made me think.
After the Bolshoi's hammy trapdoors and moving tree branch, it was lovely to see a simple and effective second act with sufficient but not overpowering mists and lightening. Overall a lovely production I thought- much as I really enjoy re-workings of the classics like Matthew Bourne's, for me, the traditional version with some individual twists like this really wins.