Jump to content

ENBlover

Members
  • Posts

    185
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by ENBlover

  1. To be honest, there's no need to compare Osipova and Obraztsova - two completely different interpretations by two completely different ballerinas, both in terms of their background and style.  I felt that both interpretations worked perfectly and were well supported by Steven and Mathew.  I did like the company overall much more last night (and happy the spakles flied for the recorded performance).  Can't wait to watch it somewhere on the screen. 

    • Like 6
  2. 'so sure her love for Gremin' I'm not so sure about that.

     

    Tatiana does display a lot of true affection and love for Gremin in the scene that precedes her last pdd with Onegin.  I thought it was acted subtly, but with a lot of real warmth and feeling towards Tatiana's husband.  I don't think it's possible to understand Tatiana's ultimate rejection of Onegin without appreciating how much she's grown to love Gremin.

    • Like 3
  3. I don't think any one of us holds the rights to how different parts could be interpreted.  While Osipova is a vibrant dancers, I have never felt that she could be blamed of self-indulgence, trying to outdance her partner or steal the limelight.  There is nothing remotely diva-esque in her performances and demeanor. 

     

    She is Russian after all - can't she dance a Turgenev character as she feels her?  Maybe she has a point she wants to make after all.

    • Like 8
  4. Alright then, I'll defend my "flat" comment.  It might seem absolutely ridiculous, but once Carlos's shoes started squeaking in the first act, the fourth wall was broken and I couldn't get into the relationship between the people on stage.  I had a few goosebump moments, but the performace just didn't become whole for me at the end.  Take it with as much a pinch of salt as you want.  I'll go back in two weeks and if Carlos's shoes keep making funny noises while their owner is confessing his love to Manon I'll be ready for it.    

    • Like 1
  5. Osipova's dancing could not be faulted but for me she was Osipova dancing Manon rather than Manon                   

     

    I always prefer it when artists bring their interpretations and personality to the part.  It doesn't always pay off, but you always treasure the moment when it does.  I definitely saw and felt her as Manon albeit a different kind of Manon.  The fact she gave me a new perspective on the character is the reason I go to the theatre.  I'm seeing this cast again and am intrigued to know how I'll feel about it on my second viewing. 

    • Like 5
×
×
  • Create New...